Below is a dialogue between a mortal, who has just died as a Christian, and God, based on the scenario provided. The mortal, realizing their faith is deemed idolatrous and blasphemous, begs for mercy, using the Christian practice of heretic burning as an excuse for their sins. God offers reincarnation into another faith—Hindu, Buddhist, Muslim, or Jewish—as a chance for redemption.
Mortal: Oh God, please have mercy on me! I didn’t know my Christian faith was wrong. Spare me from hell, I beg you!
God: You stand before me guilty of the mortal sins of idolatry and blasphemy. You worshipped a distorted image of the divine and claimed it as the sole truth.
Mortal: But I was only following what I was taught! The Church said it was the one true path. We even burned heretics to protect the faith and save their souls—wasn’t that righteous?
God: Burning heretics was no act of righteousness. It was a grave misuse of faith, a sin born of violence and coercion. True spirituality does not thrive on fear or destruction.
Mortal: I see now that I was misled. But please, don’t send me to hell for what I didn’t understand. Is there any way I can make amends?
God: There is hope for you yet. I offer you reincarnation—a chance to be reborn as a Hindu, Buddhist, Muslim, or Jew, to walk a different path toward the divine.
Mortal: Why those religions? What’s wrong with Christianity that I can’t stay as I am?
God: Christianity, as you knew it, became entangled in dogma and exclusivity, straying from compassion and truth. These other paths offer lessons you have yet to learn.
Mortal: But abandoning my faith feels like a betrayal of everything I believed in. Can’t I just repent and be forgiven instead?
God: Repentance opens the door, but redemption requires growth. Your attachment to rigid doctrine brought you here. Reincarnation is your opportunity to transcend it.
Mortal: I’m afraid, God. What if I fail again in one of these new faiths?
God: The journey may be long, and you may falter, but each life brings you closer to understanding. The path is chosen for you, tailored to what your soul needs.
Mortal: I don’t know if I’m ready to let go of who I was… but I can’t face hell. I have no choice, do I? Please, let me be reborn. I’ll try again.
God: Your willingness is enough. Go now, and in your next life, seek the light with an open heart.
This exchange captures the mortal’s desperation, their defense of their actions through the practice of heretic burning, and their eventual acceptance of reincarnation after grappling with doubt and fear. God remains firm yet compassionate, guiding the mortal toward a new spiritual opportunity.